|
Keesha sees her classmate Sunny in the common room of their dorm.
Keesha: Hey, Sunny! How was your friend’s wedding?
Sunny: Oh, it was like a fairy tale!
Keesha: Really? That’s too bad! What happened?
Sunny: What do you mean, “too bad?” I said it was “like a fairy tale.” Fairy tales are sweet and beautiful!
Keesha: No they are not!
Sunny: They are not?
Keesha: No! They are full of violence and sex and really disgusting things.
Sunny: Keesha, what are you talking about? Haven’t you seen “Snow White” or “Sleeping Beauty?” Or the more recent “Tangled?”
Keesha: Sure. But have you actually read the Brothers Grimm?
Sunny: Oh, those German guys who collected fairy tales? Yeah, I think I had a children’s book with some stories...
Keesha: Children’s books. Right. Well, when the brothers published their first edition — 200 years ago this year — with 86 stories, they were criticized.
Sunny: Because?
Keesha: Well, not only were the stories too scholarly — the Grimms were philologists collecting to preserve folk traditions — but also there was too much sex and violence in the stories for kids!
Sunny: So what did they do?
Keesha: They toned them down, a little. But Disney and other filmmakers have really taken the bite out of them.
Sunny: For example?
Keesha: Let’s see: You know the Frog Prince?
Sunny: When the princess kisses the frog?
Keesha: Uh-uh. She doesn’t kiss him. She throws him against a wall!
Sunny: Really?
Keesha: Yeah. And you mentioned “Tangled,” about the girl Rapunzel?
Sunny: Yes. It’s so romantic.
Keesha: Kidnapping? Imprisonment? Not so romantic.
Sunny: I guess you are right. What about Snow White?
Keesha: A stepmother who wants the girl killed because she is beautiful? And she wants to eat her heart?
Sunny: I see what you mean.
Keesha: The stories are really horrifying. Still, in a way, they are great, because they address some deep psychological issues. Freud, Jung, and others have used them in studying human psychology.
Sunny: In what way?
Keesha: I do not have time to tell you now. Maybe another day.
Sunny: I’m looking forward to it. See ya!
Keesha: Bye.
Notes on the dialogue:
— Philologist: someone who studies language, especially the history of language as found in written sources.
— To tone something down: to soften something.
— Freud: Sigmund Freud (1856-1939), Austrian doctor who founded the science of psychoanalysis.
— Jung: Carl Jung (1875-1961), Swiss psychiatrist and a student of Freud.
— Folk traditions: the stories, art, music, and so on of “the people.”
— To take the bite out of something: same as tone something down.
*****--Uh-uh: “No.”
|